top of page

Cover art has bigger problems than genAI

Writer: Micah Kolding
Micah Kolding
2 hours ago
3 min read

What happened to cover art? I'm not even talking about the genAI slop, either; I'm talking about the covers of books that actually matter. They've had serious issues for a long while now, and it's time we called it out.


Behold, a sampling of covers from two contemporary, traditionally published series. The first series is about a young girl who solves mysteries as a spell-slinging agent for a department charged with managing the magical world that walks among us. The second series is about a grown-ass man who does roughly the same thing. Despite my glib summarizations, they are very different characters who use very different magic rules to fight very different monsters and solve very different mysteries, but you wouldn't really know that by looking at these:


Two series with two distinctly different audiences, and what do they give us? Six pictures of a protagonist striking a nondescript pose while some nondescript magic maybe happens around them. If you look closely, and if you've already read the novel, you can identify a few salient props and events, but that doesn't do any good to someone trying to decide whether or not to invest the time. Facial expressions all fall somewhere on a spectrum that starts with "dead-eyed stare" and ends with "I shouldn't have eaten that entire lemon a few minutes ago". There is no personality, no action, and nothing that hints at anything special going on beyond this cover.


It's baffling to realize that this is what comes out of established publishing houses that frequently bemoan the difficulty of cutting through the noise in such a highly competitive marketplace. These are the people who write articles and give seminars on how authors need to be able to market their books to them; give us a unique hook! How are you different from all the other novels out there? You have precious few seconds to get my attention; USE THEM WISELY OR SUFFER! And then they put out lackluster covers for books with uninteresting titles and back-cover text that delivers some variation on "Protagonist Goodguy was just a normal kid, until events and situations turned his world upside-down!"


It's a far cry from many of the books that drew me in as a kid. I think back to the original Harry Potter cover they published in the US, where a spritely young British schoolboy was making a flying leap on a boomstick to catch a winged bauble. This was a fun cover. You may not know what's going on any more than you do with the above examples, but there was a specificity to the magic that invited imagination, and a humanity to the character that invited engagement. Potential readers weren't simply expected to think, "Hey, magic; that's fun, right?" They were thinking, "What's going on with this ordinary-ass kid in a rugby shirt flying on a broomstick? I want to fly!"


And frankly, this should be the fun side of marketing. It's not the soul-crushing grind of trying to get your book out in the world. It's a picture, FFS. People love to create pictures. I personally draw artwork and even theoretical covers for my projects simply because I feel like it. The following, for example, is a rough design of what a cover for the second WHAT Files novel might look like:

I acknowledge that I'm not even very good at drawing, but I've found that people respond to my style anti-regardless. While people enjoy good technique, it's the evocation of imagination that really carries a piece. In this one, I drew upon the story's salient theme of Wonderland to stage the classic Mad Tea Party scene with my own characters. The pairing of the familiar with the unfamiliar challenges viewers; why is the Mad Hatter portrayed by a lady clown? Why is the March Hare portrayed by the Easter Bunny? Is the Dormouse some kind of evil Pikachu? These are the thousand words that a picture is supposed to be worth, and they're giving the audience a sense of what makes this story unique. And, best of all, it's an image that an AI would never, never be able to replicate.


When people say that you can't judge a book by its cover, this isn't supposed to be a marketing guideline; in an ideal world, you should absolutely, 100% be able to make a fair assessment of a book based on its cover. That's what it's there for. And if we could expect more books to put a little more soul and artistry into their covers, perhaps we wouldn't have to feel so threatened by soulless, artless genAI slop covers.

 
 
 

Comments


©2018 by Tales from the Plot Hole. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page